Best Toaster Reviews

I’m Alex and I write toaster reviews. I have tried so many top rated toasters on the market and compiled my best toaster reviews in this blog. I aim to give my readers a better picture on what is the best toaster to buy.

Do check out my toaster buying guide if you are shopping for a toaster. Feel free to look around and hopefully my reviews will help you find your best pop-up toaster.

How to Buy the Best Toaster

2-Slice Toaster or 4-Slice Toaster
2 slice 4 slice toasters
First off you should figure out how much toast you want to make. The most common toasters that can be found on the market come in the two slice and four slice capacity. Simple math tells us that the four slice toaster makes toast twice as quickly as the two slice toaster, so if you have a lot of toast to make in the morning, the four slice toaster is a better choice.

Long Slot Toaster
long slot toaster
If you toast irregular sized or large homemade bread slices, the long slot toaster is what you’ll need. Long slot toasters commonly come with only two long slots and they are able to toast two long slices or four regular slices at one go.

Plastic Toaster or Metal Toaster
plastic metal toaster
Next comes the build, you can either choose a plastic toaster that is generally less durable but cheaper or a metallic toaster that is sturdier but will cost a little more. Stainless steel toasters or toasters with other metal finish have a cool exterior that won’t burn your hand. Toasters these days come in all sorts of colors and designs so there is no harm being overly picky on the aesthetics of the toaster because you’re bound to find something that suits you. Recently, there are even a few glass toasters on the market but these toasters are extremely rare.

What is the Best Toaster?

There are a few criterias that every good toaster should have.

  • Removable Crumb Tray – This is essential because it is nearly impossible to clean a toaster without one. if your toaster comes without a crumb tray, you probably have to turn your toaster upside down and keep shaking it till every single crumb is out (highly unlikely).
  • High Lift Carriage – This is to avoid you having to claw into your toaster when a slice of toast gets stuck. The high lift carriage or lever functions as a safety net that propels your slice of bread upwards.
  • Even Heating – Who doesn’t want perfect toast? Even heating is what really separates the best toaster from an average toaster.
  • Wide Slots – Slots should be wide enough to accommodate more than the regular slices of bread, so that you can toast bagels, thick slices, English muffins and more.
  • Heat Dial/Browning Options – I like my toast slightly more crispy while my wife prefers hers on the lighter side so for people like us, a temperature dial or several options for toast shade is crucial.

Best Toaster Reviews 2015

Now you know what to look out for in a toaster, here is a list of the best toasters that I have tested.

Best 4 Slice Toaster

Cuisinart CPT-440 Touch to Toast Leverless 4-Slice ToasterThe first thing I thought of when I saw this toaster was how well designed it looked. The stainless steel finish is a nice touch that accentuates the dual LCD screens. The absence of the conventional lever also fits in well with the futuristic feel and design of the toaster.

What Can It Do?

This toaster excels at toasting bread and bagels alike. The CPT 440 even has enhanced bagel functions that ensure you only get the best treatment for your bagels. The toaster has a motorized lift that automatically lifts and lowers your toast so no buttons or levers are required.

This toaster also features extra wide slots and a 7 shade toast setting that would indeed be perfect for any sort of toast. The three year warranty is considered long for modern toasters and you know what they say about long warranties indicating high quality.

Biggest Complaint

My toaster was perfect, the shade of toast that came out was spot on and I never once had an issue with the lift. However, a couple of other reviewers had mentioned uneven toasting and a malfunctioning motorized lift.

Read my best 4 slice toaster review here or see the best price here.

Best 2 Slice Toaster

KitchenAid KMT223CU 2 slice toasterThe Kitchenaid KMT 223CU is the best two slice toaster I have tested. It is a futuristic toaster that features a fully automatic design and has no levers. This is a real solid toaster with a full metal construction, so you don’t really have to be too gentle with it.

What Can It Do?

The KMT 223CU can toast sliced bread, bagels and even has a defrost feature. Like most of the more modern toasters, the KMT 223CU uses a low heat to keep your toast warm when it’s done toasting. The reheat feature is also a nice addition. Sometimes I toast extra slices of bread in the morning and don’t finish it. I usually pop these unfinished slices in the fridge. I can reheat my toast without burning it which is really convenient.

Biggest Complaint

My only complaint for this toaster is the beeper that indicated my toast was ready. It’s way too loud. Almost as loud as an alarm clock. If you love a quiet morning you’re going to hate the beeper.

Read my full review for the best two slice toaster or see the best price here.

Best Cheap 2-Slice Toaster

Conair Cuisinart CPT-122 2 slice toasterPriced below $30, the Conair Cuisinart CPT-122 is the best cheap toaster you can buy. It has a 7 setting shade dial which is used to control how brown your toast becomes, which would be perfect for families who prefer different shades of toast. The toaster has a compact yet retro design that helps with easy storage and thanks to its light weight, it is easy to move the toaster around.

What Can It Do?

Using this toaster, you’d be able to reheat or toast anything from large slices of bread to English muffins and bagels thanks to the 1-1/2-inch wide toasting slots. The raised carriage built into the toaster was also a nice addition to ensure none of what we toasted ever got stuck in the toaster.

Biggest Complaint

There was only one major complaint by several users about the uneven heating mechanism of the toaster. I on the other hand didn’t encounter any such problem so it may have been a manufacture defect. The toaster comes with a three year warranty so you could take the risk here and send it back if there are any defects.

Read my full review for the best cheap toaster or see the best price here.

Best Toaster Brands

Not every toaster model that is produced by the best brands on the market are worth purchasing. Anyway, I have grouped all of my best toaster reviews here according to their brands. It’ll be easier for those who have a favorite brand to look up a newer or better model here. These reviews are my first hand accounts for trying these toasters. It’s good to know what you’re getting out of a toaster before purchasing it. There is hardly anything you can do to a badly built toaster to make it give you good toast.

Hamilton Beach
Morphy Richards

All right, more to come soon! I will be reviewing the best long slot toasters, stainless steel toasters, retro toasters and even Star Wars toasters! Meanwhile, remember to bookmark my blog for more toaster review updates!